Ever wondered why your manufacturing costs sometimes seem off, even when your production runs as planned? If so, you’re not alone—many manufacturers puzzle over mysterious fluctuations in overhead costs.
Understanding when and why manufacturing overhead becomes overallocated is crucial for controlling budgets and making smart business decisions. This article dives into the key reasons overallocation happens, explains its impact, and shares practical tips for identifying and preventing it, so your production numbers stay accurate and reliable.
Related Video
What Causes Overallocated Manufacturing Overhead?
Overallocated manufacturing overhead happens when the amount of overhead assigned to products (called applied overhead) is greater than the actual manufacturing overhead costs incurred during a specific period. In simple terms, you’ve estimated and allocated more manufacturing costs to your products than you actually spent.
Breaking It Down
In manufacturing, overhead includes indirect costs required for production. These might be:
- Factory rent
- Equipment depreciation
- Utilities
- Indirect labor (such as supervisors or maintenance workers)
Instead of waiting until the end of the period to see the actual costs, companies estimate these costs and allocate them throughout the year according to a predetermined overhead rate. This is based on expected expenses and a chosen activity base—often direct labor hours, machine hours, or units produced.
Overallocated overhead occurs when applied overhead (what you’ve charged to jobs based on estimates) is higher than the actual costs you’ve incurred.
The Core Explanation
Manufacturing overhead is overallocated when:
Applied (allocated) overhead > Actual overhead costs incurred
Or, to phrase it another way:
– You estimated costs and budgeted for more overhead than you actually used.
Why Does Overallocation Happen?
Several factors can lead to overallocated overhead:
- Overestimated Activity: You predicted you’d use more labor or machine hours than you actually did.
- Overestimated Expenses: Your expected costs for rent, utilities, or supplies were higher than reality.
- Improper Predetermined Rate: The overhead rate was set too high due to inaccurate estimates.
Example
Suppose your company estimated $120,000 in overhead for the year, expecting 10,000 direct labor hours.
– Predetermined Rate = $120,000 / 10,000 hours = $12 per labor hour
If you actually worked 8,000 labor hours, you’d apply $96,000 in overhead ($12 × 8,000 hours).
But what if the actual overhead costs came out to just $80,000?
– Applied overhead = $96,000
– Actual overhead = $80,000
– Overallocated by $16,000
Steps in Overhead Allocation and Corrections
1. Estimate Overhead Costs
Before the year begins, companies estimate total overhead and the activity base.
2. Calculate Predetermined Overhead Rate
The basic formula:
Predetermined Overhead Rate = Estimated Total Manufacturing Overhead ÷ Estimated Total Amount of Allocation Base
3. Apply Overhead
As jobs are completed, overhead is applied using:
Applied Overhead = Predetermined Overhead Rate × Actual Amount of Allocation Base Used
4. Compare Applied and Actual Overhead
At the end of the period, compare total applied overhead to actual overhead incurred:
- If Applied > Actual: Overallocated
- If Applied < Actual: Underallocated
5. Adjust in the Accounts
Any overallocated (or underallocated) overhead must be adjusted. Common practices include:
- Closing the variance to Cost of Goods Sold (COGS)
- Allocating it proportionally to WIP, Finished Goods, and COGS
Why Manufacturing Companies Should Care
Manufacturing overhead allocation directly impacts product costing, pricing, and profitability. Overallocation (and its opposite, underallocation) can distort your cost information and financial statements.
Key Implications of Overallocated Overhead
- Product Cost Distortion: Your products might seem more expensive than they actually were to produce.
- Pricing Mistakes: Higher reported costs can lead to higher sales prices, possibly making you less competitive.
- Inventory Valuation Issues: Ending inventory may be overstated due to excess overhead applied.
- Tax and Profit Reporting: Incorrect COGS can misstate gross profit and taxable income.
Challenges in Managing Overhead Allocation
Overallocating overhead is a common issue, but several challenges make it hard to avoid:
- Changing Activity Levels: Production can be higher or lower than forecasted.
- Economic Fluctuations: Costs like utilities can vary unexpectedly.
- Labor Changes: Overtime, training, or personnel changes impact activity bases.
Practical Tips and Best Practices
Here are ways to reduce the risk of overallocation:
1. Regularly Review Estimates
Update your overhead rates periodically—at least annually, or whenever significant changes occur.
2. Use Accurate, Dynamic Allocation Bases
Choose bases (such as machine hours or labor hours) that closely match how overhead is actually incurred.
3. Leverage Technology
Automate data collection for better accuracy on activity levels and cost tracking.
4. Perform Frequent Variance Analysis
Compare applied versus actual overhead regularly, not just at year-end. This helps catch major differences early.
5. Train Your Team
Ensure that your accounting staff understands the importance of careful estimation and the impact of over/underapplied overhead.
6. Adjust Overhead Rates as Needed
If you spot continuous over- or underallocation, adjust your predetermined rate as soon as possible.
How to Correct Overallocated Overhead
When you identify that overhead is overallocated, it’s essential to fix it so your financial records are accurate.
Common Approaches
- Close the Difference to Cost of Goods Sold (COGS)
- If the overallocated amount is minimal, adjust COGS directly.
-
For example:
- Debit Manufacturing Overhead
- Credit COGS
-
Proportionally Allocate to Inventory Accounts
- If the overallocated amount is significant, distribute the adjustment across WIP, Finished Goods, and COGS.
- This keeps inventory values fair and compliant with accounting standards.
Example Journal Entry for Overallocated Overhead
If overhead is overapplied by $10,000:
– Debit Manufacturing Overhead $10,000
– Credit Cost of Goods Sold $10,000
This removes the excess cost from your expense accounts, bringing the costs in line with reality.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What is manufacturing overhead?
Manufacturing overhead refers to all indirect costs required to produce goods, such as factory rent, utilities, indirect materials, and indirect labor. These are costs that can’t be directly traced to a single product.
What causes overhead to be overallocated?
Overallocated overhead happens when the overhead applied to production (based on estimates) is higher than the actual overhead costs incurred. Causes include overestimating activity levels, setting the predetermined overhead rate too high, or incurring lower-than-expected actual costs.
How can overallocated overhead affect financial statements?
Overallocated overhead can make product costs and inventories appear higher than they truly are, inflating cost of goods sold and affecting reported gross profit. This can lead to misinformed business decisions, pricing errors, and misstated income.
How often should manufacturing companies review their overhead allocation?
You should review overhead allocation at least annually, but more frequent checks—quarterly or monthly—are highly recommended, especially in industries with volatile costs or production levels.
How is overallocated overhead corrected in accounting records?
To correct overallocated overhead, you typically reduce cost of goods sold by the overapplied amount. If the variance is significant, you may allocate the adjustment proportionally among work in process, finished goods, and cost of goods sold for more accurate inventory valuation.
In Summary
Overallocated manufacturing overhead is a common issue in cost accounting. It results when more overhead is applied to jobs than was actually incurred. This occurs because of imperfect estimates and unpredictable changes in costs and activity levels. While it’s a routine outcome of using predetermined rates, careful estimation, regular monitoring, and timely adjustments can help keep your cost accounting accurate—and your business decisions smart.
By understanding and addressing overallocated overhead, you ensure your product costing remains transparent, competitive, and reliable. Regular analysis and willingness to adjust your approach will help you avoid costly miscalculations, keeping your manufacturing operation financially healthy.
